| Dates | Player | College | Accomplishments |
| 1932-1935 | George Brungard | Ohio State | 3 yr starter O & D Line |
| 1938-1942 | Dick “Sonny” Fisher | Ohio State | 3 yr starter football & basketball: Leading rusher in Big Ten 1942 “The Original Clipper” |
| 1944-1949 | Bill Newell | Ohio State | 3 yr letterman Starting HB 1950 Rose Bowl |
| 1945-1949 | Don Evans | Mount Union | 4 yr letterman |
| 1953-1959 | Don McBride | Ohio | 2 yr starting Quarterback |
| 1958-1962 | Bill Davidson | Youngstown State | 4 yr starter TE & DT |
| 1966-1970 | Dick Keller | Delaware | 3 yr starter OLB D2 National Champions |
| 1967-1971 | Randy Bollsinger | Rutgers | 3 yr letterman |
| 1967-1969 | Rick Perrin | Bowling Green | 2 yr starter WR 1965-1967 Harvard letter in track & basketball 1970-1973 NY Giants |
| 1968-1972 | George Lynn | Wittenberg | 3 yr letterman Played in 1st ever D3 National Championship 1969 |
| 1971-1975 | Don Schmidt | Grove City | 3 yr letterman Captain and defensive MVP 1974 |
| 1971-1975 | Jeff Stevens | Mount Union | 3 yr letterman |
| 1973-1976 | Kevin Goist | West Liberty State | 2 yr letterman, starting punter Letter in track 1971-1973 Played basketball @ Wheeling College |
| 1977-1982 | Ron Kissel | Youngstown State | 4 yr letterman, 3 yr starter DT NCAA 1-AA National Runner Up |
| 1978-1982 | Mike Flohr | Ohio Wesleyan | 3 yr letterman; captain |
| 1978-1983 | Jeff Johnston | Youngstown State | Starting FB on national runner up & championship teams |
| 1987-1991 | Rick Clark | Baldwin Wallace | 3 yr letterman; 2 yr starter O Line |
| 1991-1996 | Curt Wiekart | Marietta | OAC Offensive Player of the Year in 1995 1st Team OAC, 1st Team D3 All-American @ TB |
| 1994-1998 | Toby Bacon | Otterbein | 3 yr letterman; captain All-OAC 1st Team D Line |
| 1995-2000 | Mike Winter | Saginaw Valley State | 3 yr letterman |
| 1996-2000 | Mike Bettura | Marietta | 3 yr letterman |
| 1998-2003 | Jason Morris | Carnegie Mellon | 3 yr starter at DB |
| 1998-2002 | Jason Stefanick | Mercyhurst | G.L.A.C. 1st team All-Academic LB 2001 |
| 1998-2002 | Justin Stefanick | Mercyhurst | G.L.A.C. 1st team All-Academic DE 2001 |
| 1999-2004 | Drew Garrod | Carnegie Mellon | 3 yr starter Wing Back/Return Specialist Led division 3 in return yardage 2003 |
| 2000-2004 | Jared Work | Mercyhurst | 2 yr letterman |
| 2001-2005 | J.D. Patton | Case Western Reserve | 3 yr starter DB Single game record for interceptions |
| 2001-2005 | Drew Crider | John Carroll | 2 yr letterman |
| 2002-2006 | Derek Garrod | Ohio Northern | 3 yr starter at TB |
| 2003-2008 | Tim Reash | Mount Union | 3 yr starter Offensive Guard 3 time D3 National Champion 1st Team All-OAC; 24-0 as starter |
| 2004-2008 | Greg Sell | Seton Hill | 3 yr letterman football; 4 yr letterman track |
| 2006-2010 | Mike Welce | Walsh | 3 yr starter strong safety/OLB 1st team all league; Defensive MVP |
| 2007-2011 | Joey Winters | Washington & Jefferson | 2 yr letterman |
| 2008-2012 | Josh Hertel | Johns Hopkins | 3 yr starter FB 2011 Div. 3 playoffs- 11-0 record |
| 2008-2012 | Ryan Williams | Waynesburg | 3 yr letterman; 2 yr starting strong safety 1st Team PAC 2011 |
| 2009-2011 | Beau Papania | John Carroll | 2 yr letterman Played 2006-2008 @ Walsh University |
| 2009-2013 | Josh Harold | Mercyhurst | 2 yr letterman |
| 2009-2014 | Jonathan Welsh | Theil | 3 yr letterman; 2 yr starter offensive guard |
| 2010-2015 | Rex Smith | Theil | 3 yr letterman |
| 2011-2016 | Trenton Solman | Walsh | 2 yr letterman |
| 2011-2016 | Nick McMillian | Tiffin | 2 yr letterman |
| 2014-2018 | Mike Buzzard | Ashland | 4 yr letterman |
Columbiana Clipper Football 