The Associated Press (aka AP) and United Press International (aka UPI) began naming a High School All-Star Team in the late 1920’s. By the 1940’s Ohio was divided into two divisions; a Class A for large schools and Class B for smaller schools. By the 1950’s it was reclassified to A and AA. By the 1970’s three classifications were introduced A, AA, and AAA as the number of schools playing interscholastic sports increased. By the late 70’s when post season playoffs came on the scene football was broken into five divisions and the All-State team followed. In 1994, the OHSAA added a sixth division in football and in 2014 a seventh division was added thus increasing the number of All-State players also.
| All State Offensive Lineman | All State Offensive “Skill” Players | All State Defensive Players |
| George Lynn- 1967 HM Guard | Bill Newell- 1945 2nd Team HB | Gary Birmingham-1973 2nd Team DE |
| Bill Cyrus- 1967 1st Team Tackle | Don McBride- 1953 2nd Team QB | Dennis Butterly- 1977 HM D Line |
| Ron Kissel- 1977 2nd Team Guard | Dale Murphy- 1961 HM FB | Ron Kissel- 1977 1st Team D Line |
| Sean Brown- 1991 HM Center | Bill Ward- 1967 2nd Team HB | Mike Flohr- 1977 1st Team D Line |
| Josh Green- 1991 1st Team Guard | Jeff Johnston- 1976 HM FB | Mike Barnes- 1977 HM DB |
| Kevin Finley- 1993 HM Guard | Scott Knox- 1981 HM QB | Mike Birmingham- 1978 HM LB |
| Eric Neiheisel- 1993 HM Tackle | Scott Belding- 1981 HM WR | Jeff Garrity- 1978 HM |
| J.C. Caffro- 1994 1st Team Center | Bruce Kozma- 1993 HM RB | Mike Birmingham- 1979 HM LB |
| Justin Stefanick- 1997 1st Team Guard | Mike Winters- 1994 1st Team QB & NEIOD Offensive POY | Troy Berdine- 1984 1st Team DB |
| Tim Reash- 2002 2nd Team Tackle | Zach Schmidt- 1996 HM WR | Wayne Finley- 1984 2nd Team D Line |
| Mike Geer- 2003 HM Tackle | Jason Morris- 1997 1st Team QB | Chris Dudash- 1984 HM LB |
| Tyler Best- 2005 2nd Team Guard | Derek Garrod- 2000 2nd Team QB | Bob Kimpel- 1985 HM DB |
| Ben Gerlach- 2007 HM Tackle | Derek Garrod- 2001 2nd Team QB | Jerry Kimpel- 1985 HM LB |
| Mike McMaster- 2008 HM Center | Mike Welce- 2005 1st team QB & NEIOD Offensive POY | Burt Perkins- 1986 HM LB |
| Mike McMaster- 2009- 2nd Team Center | Joe Winters- 2006 2nd Team RB | Rob Stoy- 1986 HM DB |
| Matt Douglas- 2009 HM Tackle | Brian Worchol- 2008 HM RB | Rob Stoy- 1987 HM DB |
| Matt Douglas- 2010 2nd Team Tackle | Josh Harold- 2008 1st team K | Curt Weikart- 1990 1st Team LB |
| Erik Hopfenziz- 2018 3rd Team Tackle | Austin Barbato- 2010 HM QB | Curt Weikart- 1991 1st Team LB |
| Jake Ward- 2015 1st Team WR | Eric Strohecker- 1991 1st Team DE | |
| Mitch Davidson- 2015 1st Team QB | Rick Cusick- 1991 1st Team DB | |
| Mitch Davidson- 2016 1st Team QB | Jeff Remish- 1991 1st Team D Line | |
| Jared Bryarly- 2017 HM K | Jeff Remish- 1992 1st Team D Line Div. 5 Defensive POY | |
| Jakob Cross- 2019 HM QB | Robert Mook- 1992 HM DB | |
| Toby Bacon- 1993 2nd Team D Line | ||
| Steve Smith- 1994 1st Team DE | ||
| John Hawkins- 1994 HM LB | ||
| Jason Stefanick- 1997 1st Team LB Div. 6 Defensive POY | ||
| Joe McAndrew- 1997 HM DB | ||
| Paul Altomare- 1997 HM D Line | ||
| Bob Brown- 1998 HM DE | ||
| Drew Garrord- 1998 HM DB | ||
| Drew Crider- 2000 HM DB | ||
| J.P. Jenkins- 2001 HM DE | ||
| John Tollas JR.- 2002 HM LB | ||
| Tye Crider- 2003 2nd Team DB | ||
| Adam Fast- 2003 2nd Team LB | ||
| Chris McIntyre- 2005 HM D Line | ||
| Chris McIntyre- 2006 1st Team D Line Div. 6 Defensive POY | ||
| Cory Guy- 2006 HM DB | ||
| Mackie McGarry- 2006 HM LB | ||
| Josh Hertel- 2007 1st Team LB Div. 6 Defensive POY | ||
| Ryan Williams- 2007 1st Team DB | ||
| Grant Crider- 2009 2nd Team DB | ||
| Trent Solmen 2011 HM DE | ||
| Mike Buzzard- 2012 HM D Line | ||
| Brandon Hacker- 2012 HM LB | ||
| Britton Steigina 2012 HM DB | ||
| Mike Buzzard- 2013 HM D Line | ||
| Keenan Green- 2015 HM D Line | ||
| Keenan Green- 2016 HM D Line | ||
| Cody Miller- 2019 HM D Line | ||